Student-Athletes eligibility guidelines include:
- Induction eligibility beginning after five years from final intercollegiate athletic participation;
- Minimum qualifications of one or more of the following: All-Conference selection, special conference award recipient, NAIA statistical leader, Brenau University single season and/or career statistical leader, All-American selection, NAIA national award recipient or other accomplishment;
- No more than four individuals from all sports may be inducted from this category each year;
Coach/Administrator/staff eligibility guidelines include:
- Induction eligibility beginning after five years after departure/retirement from Brenau University;
- Minimum qualifications of having coached or worked at Brenau University for four years;
- No more than one individual may be inducted in this category each year;
Friend of Athletics eligibility guidelines include:
- Induction eligibility beginning five years after commencing significant involvement with Brenau University Athletics;
- Minimum qualifications of having made a significant contribution to the athletic department, team or specific event;
- No more than one individual may be inducted in this category each year;